The Bachelor: Behind the Scenes

Sheena Stewart may not have lassoed a proposal from hunky star Brad Womack when she appeared on ABC’s The Bachelor last season. But the Northgate High alum will forever have stories to tell.

There was the day that she showed up for a date at an over-the-top beach house in Malibu only to find that Lindsay Lohan’s stuff was strewn all over the place. “She hadn’t had a chance to move out because she had been arrested [for a DUI],” says Stewart. And then there was the fall, when Stewart wiped out going down a staircase in a gown and heels. The fall was on Jimmy Kimmel the next night. (Kimmel’s “Falling with the Stars” reel also included a Fidel Castro nosedive and Marie Osmond fainting on Dancing with the Stars.)

Maybe it was the champagne, the celebrity spotlight, or the Chopard diamond earrings she received during a “fantasy date” as she made her way to the final four, but Stewart says she actually fell for Womack—just before he sent her packing.

The 23-year-old Stewart shouldn’t take the rejection too personally—Womack sent the other three bachelorettes home as well, the first time in The Bachelor’s 11 seasons that the show didn’t have a happy ending.